Legacy Of Yalta (Part One)
惜秦皇汉武,略输文采;
唐宗宋祖,稍逊风骚。
一代天骄,成吉思汗,只识弯弓射大雕。
- 红朝始皇 毛泽东 《沁园春·雪》

The importance of ordering
[N.B. As hinted, there have been disagreements over the relative positions of the Emperors; Putin would be presented front and centre at his home ground of Yalta in Crimea, with AFP going against the grain by having GOD-EMPEROR TRUMP in the middle. The actual summit would however have Xi in that position without exception, which however is only to be expected for the host.]
(Sources: thinkchina.com [twice], afp.com)
The historic Summit of Three Emperors has just been held in Shenzhen as foreshadowed last month, and has proven to be a sufficiently monumentous event to warrant a dedicated blog post. And as postulated last week, China were indeed not ready to commit to a nuclear weapon ratio that does not correspond to their standing, with Ukraine also entirely left out of the trio's official declaration towards (world) peace. Indeed, a number of observations previously made here have been duly borne out in the proceedings, and shall be addressed in turn.
There has, unfortunately, not been a cheeky reenactment of the famous Yalta photograph that had Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin seated shoulder-to-shoulder, and about this it might firstly be said that the exact form of that photo may owe much to the personal circumstances of then-POTUS Roosevelt, specifically his paralysis that prevented him from standing for any length of time (usually attributed to polio, but contested nowadays). One suspects that this obliged the organizers of the various major conferences during World War II to stage the Allied leaders sitting instead of standing, though the practice persisted at least until Potsdam in July 1945, by which time FDR had passed.
There would be no lack of historical references by all three of TRUMP, Xi and Putin to indicate the significance and precedence of this summit, with GEOTUS TRUMP characteristically open in directly describing it as "bigger than Yalta" (and he's probably right). President Xi would be more circuitous in making the comparison, in his closing statement on how the three countries had allied then as the key anti-fascist forces. And as for Putin, he would remark that "...nobody divided up the world at Yalta. It simply codified the realities that had emerged after World War II; and when it comes to today's conflicts, the realities on the ground (i.e. pertaining to Ukraine) will have to be accepted".
Whether the latest Tsar of all Russias be right or wrong on this, it may be advisable to take the entreaties towards peace at face value for now, with leader of the free world TRUMP sagely pronouncing that "No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement", a truism apparently being disregarded by his belligerent European subjects - but more on this where appropriate later!
One Table

Knights (and Heroes) Of The Round
[N.B. Each power's flag central in their own domain.]
(Source: straitstimes.com)
The Big Three would eventually be photographed seated together in what might be the defining image of the summit - but separated by a humongous round table of the scale preferred by Tsar Putin. This was fitting given the weight of those present, however, and the expected shape of the table moreover answers why the summit was alternatively called a "banquet" in a previous post; feasts have gone well with political intrigue, through Chinese history (i.e. if one is going to backstab a guy, he should at least be fed roast duck to die for first!)
Again as suggested in the original post referencing Yalta, the order of seats would be accorded quite some importance by commentators, and it would first have to be reiterated that Xi's centrality is necessitated by his status as the host - there was simply no other position that he could reasonably have taken. The setup nonetheless was carefully arranged to imply a general equality in global rank (i.e. that of Emperor) for the three present, which might be constrasted with the audience that GOD-EMPEROR TRUMP granted to his Princes of the West (which, it might be said, was perhaps more generous than what those Princes had given their own vassals in the past)
Tsar Putin would apparently crow in TASS - Russia's state news agency - that Xi had granted him the "seat of highest honour" at his right hand, but a fuller interpretation may get more complicated. China has maintained an extremely long tradition regarding seating etiquette dating back to the I Ching and the Book of Rites (i.e. 礼记), which has south-facing as the highest honour in formal halls, and east-facing as that for banquets; following this, left has historically been accepted as superior to right by the Chinese contrary to international practice, which has been practised by the (leftist) CCP to this day.
TRUMP actually having the seat of honour, then, was pointed out by some, though it has to be said that different meanings have been suggested for banquet tables. Well, one figures that President Xi will not be offering a conclusive declaration; it is good diplomacy to allow guests - and right-hand men for that matter - to console themselves, after all.
Two Pairs

问世间情为何物,直教惺惺相惜!
[N.B. But this comradery was perhaps only inevitable; for other than each other, who has the necessary stature to truly be their friend?]
(Source: politico.eu)
Again as portended in previous posts, President Xi would take care to reciprocate GOD-EMPEROR TRUMP's gesture of meeting him on the tarmac, as Zhou Enlai had once done for Richard Nixon in Beijing. TRUMP duly saluted the assembled guard of honour in return for the red-carpet treatment, and it is hard to imagine how the summit could have gotten off to a better start.
The Greatest Game had only just gotten started, preliminaries dispensed with, and President Xi would make the opening move by pairing up with Putin to call for a fairer multipolar world model and rail against Western protectionism, because everybody and their hamster knows America's obvious reverse Kissinger/Nixon strategy of turning Russia against China by now.
It might be recognized at this point that three participants should imply three pair(ing)s if within-pair order is not considered, but the subheading implies only two because the U.S.-Russia combination remains entirely undeveloped, whatever the Reddit rabble might insinuate. The first pair, then, is the Team Red dyad of China and Russia, which has shown few signs of disunity just yet, from Xi and Putin's many interactions.
The second pair would then represent the primary geopolitical conflict of the age, that between the undisputed Team Red and Team Blue leaders, i.e. China and America. This further explains why the U.S. and Russia pairing lacks real consequence; just as Xi would not take a European leader seriously were they to claim to represent Team Blue, TRUMP has no real reason to consider Putin's authority with regards to Team Red, nukes aside (this is the equivalent of demanding to speak to the manager)

With the air of the unlucky guy forced to do the presentation alone, because his group mates are useless
(Source: yahoo.com)
The natural question, then, would be why this trilateral summit has been recognized as such a big deal even by supposed detractors, when it is simply three-fifths of the United Nations Security Council (with Team Blue Britain and France missing), which has convened through living memory. On this, Tsar Putin's provocative assertion that the former hegemonies of Europe are in "humiliating decline" may have a kernel of truth in it, if only from their response to the Ukraine crisis thus far. Frankly, when Europe's main action has been to propose a 22nd package of sanctions (because the first twenty-one fared so well), why should the Emperors bother about their opinions?
Europe have, expectedly, put up a masterclass in posturing by holding (yet another) gathering of the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin, in which the supreme irony of the German Chancellor protesting against the ability of the Yalta format to bring peace was witnessed. GEOTUS TRUMP had, of course, been through all that rubbish too often already, this being the equivalent of group mates in college who are not willing to accept his contribution towards their common assignment, while refusing to do the actual work themselves... and somehow managing to scrounge up the right excuses to present as the good guys.
Really, there was no POTUS that would be able to pretend that the other Team Blue hangers-on could be of any help here, thus the sorry sight of GOD-EMPEROR TRUMP bearing the burden of the entire liberal world order on his broad shoulders, alone against two Team Red heads. TRUMP was also more than aware of the image that would be projected by him walking on one side of Xi (with Putin on the other), and thus his keeping an additional modicum of lateral distance, while also strolling slightly ahead. Xi understood too, of course, but hospitality dictated that this compromise on protocol was accepted.
Indeed, the Red and Blue team colours have proudly been on display throughout the summit by team captains Xi and TRUMP at least, from scarves to ties; but on that last, Putin's purple (or maroon) choice could yet be a reminder for Xi not to take his support for granted too readily just yet...
Three Sovereigns

The true locus of attention
(Source: cnn.com)
As this analysis approaches its middle, a more literary turn is due, all the more given how art history has proven its worth in comprehending Iranian billboard propaganda here. Perhaps even more than the three stars of the summit, the gargantuan shanshui painting serving as the backdrop at the Kylin Villa hall (formerly hosting Kim Jong-il) may well ultimately be its most enduring symbol, from how it would be ever-present at the many bilateral meetings held there too (on which more later)
If one were to consider the painting by surface appearances, it would present as a neutral and calming landscape, the sort of which would not be out of place whatever the parties present for deliberations. A closer inspection would reveal a section of the Great Wall of China towards the bottom right, which could be taken by more-ambitious pundits as a subtle signal (and just one amongst many such signs) by China on the importance that they place towards territorial integrity - and indeed, just about every participant in the summit has made a statement against Taiwanese independence, GEOTUS TRUMP included.
Digging a little deeper into the specifics, the painting is actually quite a famous work by Guan Shanyue (关山月), entitled The Great Wall Bathed in Morning Sunlight (长城内外尽朝晖), created in 1973. More precisely, this appears to be a reproduction of the original, which has been quoted as being about two metres wide and being in the collection of the National Art Museum of China, having originally been commissioned for the Great Hall of the People in Beijing. That this came immediately after America's formal acknowledgement of One China upon Nixon's rapprochement, may be more than a simple coincidence.

Translation: Such is the enchanting beauty of this land, that it has moved countless heroes (to compete) to bow in admiration!
(Source: manhuagui.com)
The symbolism does not stop there, however, and here we turn from visual art to poetry. The painting is officially recognized as drawing inspiration from two poems by Paramount Leader (and some say first Emperor of the current dynasty of China) Mao Zedong: his 1936 work Qinyuanchun Theme: Snow (《沁园春·雪》) as well as the 1961 piece, Reply To A Friend (《七律·答友人》), from which the last three characters of the title of the painting (尽朝晖) derive.
Of these, the primary motivation would seem to be from the (much-dissected) former, of which what is perhaps its most famous line (江山如此多娇,引无数英雄竞折腰) refers to the Heroes of the Age(s) - which, by the way, had maybe been implied for TRUMP and Xi in May at their previous banquet. What may be yet more interesting would be the following few lines, as quoted at the start of this blog post; they constitute a critique of five Emperors in three groups, which may be roughly translated as:
Qin Shihuang and Han Wudi lacked a certain literary flair;
Tang Taizong and Song Taizu likewise wanting in poetic grace.
Genghis Khan, that heaven-sent prodigy of his age, knew only how to draw his bow and shoot down giant eagles.
Now, Mao might be thought to be slightly uncharitable in his dissing of his predecessors; four out of five of the Emperors listed were (co-)founders of their dynasty, after all, and it has to be said that force of arms has usually been more useful in (re-)unifying China, than the ability to rhyme (though it has to be said that some warlords were really, really bad at poetry). Moreover, it feels slightly odd to raise basically the same weakness for multiple examples, instead of pointing out different shortcomings to address.
That said, a uniform denigration of the martial focus of past Emperors is not an inappropriate angle for President Xi to approach from, given the repeated emphasis on world peace for this summit. It might however also not be missed that the arrangement naturally brings to mind Three Sovereigns (and Five Emperors; 三皇五帝), possibly targeted towards the three worthies present, and perhaps unavoidable once Xi had invited TRUMP to the Temple of Heaven, and received Putin at the same garden. Reading too much into it? Well, these are times where reading too little into symbolism may be dangerous too, and hey, Rubio did bring up Alexander, Julius and Charlemange...
[To be continued...]